The European pedagogical classic, What's the Use of Lectures?
by Donald A. Bligh, makes its American debut in this first
US edition. After three decades in circulation and approximately
forty thousand volumes in print, this is a case in which "classic"
is not misapplied. What's the Use of Lectures? is exactly
what it purports to be: a handbook on the lecture method. It is
both reference work and textbook. Bligh intended the work to be
flexible in this regard; the reader may choose only selected portions,
or may read the volume as a whole. In this way, What's the
Use of Lectures? is immediately approachable for either novice
instructors in their initial exposure to the lecture method or
the experienced lecturer seeking a refresher course. Bligh organizes
the work into five parts, each dedicated to exploring facets of
the lecture as a teaching method: What Objectives can Lectures
Achieve?, What Factors Affect the Acquisition of Information?,
What Lecture Techniques apply these Factors most Effectively?,
Alternatives when Lecturing is Inadequate, and Preparation for
the Use of Lectures. Each part is then further subdivided into
chapters.
Because What's the Use of Lectures? is geared towards the
beginning instructor (though the more experienced teacher is by
no means disenfranchised), early on our author defines the lecture,
asserting that it is "a period of more or less continuous
exposition by the teacher." (5) Bligh devotes a great deal
of attention to the purpose of the lecture as a teaching technique.
In short, Bligh identifies the lecture as being best suited for
"the acquisition of information by the students." (4)
Bligh supports this conclusion with numerous independent, educational
studies that evaluate student learning. Concomitantly, a significant
contribution of the work is Bligh's straightforward discussion
of the occasions and objectives for which the lecture is not
an appropriate teaching technique. Again based upon the results
of numerous studies, Bligh concludes that lectures are not the
best means for promoting student thought, changing student attitudes,
or teaching particular behavioral skills.
Throughout the work, Bligh maintains an awareness of the larger
pedagogical scheme, and so keeps the discussion of the lecture
within the context of other teaching methods. In addition to the
material outlining the function and proper implementation of the
lecture, perhaps the most helpful sections of What's the Use
of Lectures? are the chapters devoted to integrating the lecture
into a variety of teaching techniques. Bligh advises that the
lecture be used with discernment, towards particular goals and
outcomes, and should not be overused. The use of buzz groups,
horseshoe groups, multi-media, and student presentations are all
recommended in tandem or in combination with the lecture.
Missing from What's the Use of Lectures? is discussion
of the challenges faced by the lecturer engaged in distance learning,
especially on occasions of real-time simulcast to multiple student
audiences, and particularly given the heavy reliance on lecturing
by instructors in distance learning. Now, theoretically, there
should be no change in teaching style or objectives with this
new technology; nevertheless, advice in this arena could assuage
the practical difficulties faced by both the lecturer and students.
That said, What's the Use of Lectures? is for the most
part comprehensive and thorough. The work addresses the needs
of both the student and the lecturer. It is an extremely well
researched tome, one in which specialists in education, particularly
those whose primary interest is ways of knowing and learning,
will find engaging conversation as well as reference to a plethora
of research. Bligh brings a high level of expertise to the table,
but What's the Use of Lectures? is not so loaded with technical
jargon that only psychologists and educational specialists feel
as ease. What's the Use of Lectures? is a readable, approachable,
incisive and practical guide to classroom lecturing.
Kathleen Peters
UNC Asheville